| Platinum | Jose Pepper's Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Dos Reales |
| Silver | Sombrero's Mexican Cantina |
| Bronze | Margarita's Lenexa |
| Top Pick | Abelardo's Mexican Fresh |
| Top Pick | Al Chile |
| Top Pick | Champion Burrito's |
| Top Pick | Fronteras Mexican Restaurant & Cantina |
| Top Pick | Mi Ranchito |
| Top Pick | Tiki Taco |